Senior Medigap plans in Pennsylvania help you pay for many of the costs that Medicare does not cover, including deductibles, coinsurance, copays and other out-of-pocket expenses. We show you 2019 Supplement rates from the top insurance companies so you can make an informed decision whether you wish to purchase a plan. Of course, your quote is completely free when you provide your zip code above. Pa Advantage options and Part D prescription drug plans are also available. If your income or health change throughout the year, reviewing and comparing carrier options may save money.

Some Basic Facts:

To be eligible for a Pa supplemental plan, you must be enrolled in Part A AND B. If you have already signed up for Part A, but Part B, form CMS 40-B should be completed. Part D prescription drug benefits are also available at reduced costs, if your income is limited. The "Medicare Prescription Drug Program" can help if your combined assets are less than $27,600 (married) or $13,820) single. An application must be completed and submitted.

You can only purchase a plan from an insurer that is licensed in Pennsylvania. The Pa Department of Insurance makes the final determination. You can also view ratings and other financial data about each carrier. Network provider information is also provided.

There are state and federal laws that must be followed on every plan. Occasionally, legislative changes are introduced that can impact the price of your plan, benefits, and eligibility.

The premium you pay for your gap coverage is separate from the amount you are charged for the Part B benefits. It also is optional and not required.

You can not be terminated from your current policy because you developed a medical condition or submitted too many claims. You can also keep the plan, unless it is not offered in your service area, or the company no longer conducts business.

Unless you have a Suupplement plan, potential out-of-pocket costs are unlimited.

Unlike conventional healthcare policies, a family can not be covered under one contract. Each applicant must purchase their own policy, which means that two separate applications are processed. You can cancel at any time, and there is no extra cost for not combining policies.

If you have a Medical Savings Account (MSA), you can not purchase a Medigap policy. However, you can keep your HSA and use past deposits to pay out-of-pocket costs, such as copays, coinsurance, or deductibles. You can also switch HSA financial institutions from one bank to another. Limited-benefit coverage can also be purchased to cover specific gaps.

Many of the recent Affordable Care Act (ACA)  and Exchange changes have no impact on your policy selection or pricing options. Most of the Obamacare legislation pertains to consumers under age 65. Also, Medicaid expansion generally does not affect your choices, unless you meet certain income requirements. Also, it is possible to receive Group benefits at work after you reach age 65. It is also possible that one spouse may be covered under a Marketplace or employer-provided plan, while the other spouse utilizes Senior coverage.

Additional help is provided by SHIP (State Health Insurance Assistance Program) and the Medicare Plan Finder, which is located online.


When Can You Buy A Policy?

The most popular (and perhaps the easiest) time to purchase Medicare Supplement coverage is the 7-month Open Enrollment period. It begins when you have initially signed up for Part B and have reached age 65. During this period of time, your application is guaranteed to be approved, regardless of any past or present medical issue. Your rate will be identical to the premium charged by the insurer to all persons. Even if you have a surgery scheduled, or a condition that requires immediate treatment, it will not affect what you pay. Any current medications you take will not impact your premium.

There will be no waiting periods, increased copays or deductibles, or special surcharges. Pre-existing conditions will be covered, and you are not excluded from applying from any plan that would ordinarily be offered. However, you must only consider options in your network service area. Therefore, it is possible that specific plans will either not be available, or will have different rates, depending upon your county of residence.

For example, Highmark, UPMC, Capital Blue Cross, Geisinger, and Independence Blue Cross cover specific areas of the state, while Aetna and UnitedHealthcare have larger Pa service areas. Although Cigna does not currently offer private under age-65 products, they do offer various Senior plans. Humana offers Senior and Group products, but not individual private medical plans to applicants under age 65.

Find Cheap Pa Medigap Coverage


If you miss this 7-month window, you can still purchase a Medigap plan in Pennsylvania. However, if it is not during Open Enrollment (October 15th-December 7th), the health insurer can "underwrite" the application, meaning that it is possible that existing conditions could increase the cost. A denial of coverage is also possible. However, since each carrier has different underwriting guidelines, at least three different companies should be considered. If you don't qualify for a "Special Enrollment Period," you can also enroll between January 1 and March 31. However, the effective date will be delayed until July 1, and you might have to pay an increased premium.

If you have not reached age 65 yet, there may not be a reason to own this type of coverage. However, it is prudent to start shopping and reviewing in advance. NOTE: Many of the companies that offer Under-65 Exchange plans, do not underwrite Senior coverage. Also, in many situations, the company that provides your benefits before you reach age 65, is not the ideal choice for MedSup coverage. For example, UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, Humana, USAA, and Bankers do not participate in the Pa Marketplace. However, they offer several Senior products.


When Can You Change An Existing Policy?

As previously mentioned, each year, there is a Fall Open Enrollment from October 15th to December 7th. If you already own an existing policy, you can freely shop and change to another plan. Of course, you can also keep the same contract you have. You are not obligated to stay with the same company. For instance, you could change from Aetna to Humana, from UPMC to Highmark, from AARP to Cigna, or completely drop coverage. You can also keep the same company, but change plans.

However, if you change carriers, (Advantage coverage) it's important to verify that your physician, facility, and/or hospital is still "in-network." This would especially apply to specialists, and any type of mental or physical therapy you are receiving. It is also advisable to verify that your pharmacy will continue to work directly with your insurer when the new calendar year begins.

January 1 Starting Date

Your benefits (or changes) start on January 1 and generally, this window is the only opportunity to alter your Part D or Advantage policies. If you presently are covered under an "Advantage" plan, you can change back to original Medicare benefits. A factor in your decision to change (or not to change) could be an "Annual Notice Of Change" (ANOC) you receive. It will notify you of changes in rates, benefits and other items that could influence you to keep or adjust your existing policy. Typically, it is sent in September by your current company.

This time period also gives you the chance to review your Part D prescription drug benefits and price, and comparison-shop with other available options. You do not have to make any adjustments if you are happy with the plan you have. However, often, there may be another plan that covers your specific prescriptions less expensively with limited restrictions. Any changes to the carrier formulary drug list must also be considered when choosing plans.

Understanding the exact prescriptions and dosage you take is very important, along with properly comparing Tier 1, 2, 3, and 4 drug costs. Tier 1 generally consists of the least expensive (and often generic) drugs. Tier 4 is the most expensive classification, and is typically specialty drugs. Each carrier generally provides a "formulary drug list" that helps consumers with determining out-of-pocket costs. Whenever possible, your physician should prescribe a generic drug, if available.


Can You Apply For Medicare Benefits Online?

Yes, and you don't have to be retired yet. The process generally takes about 10-15 minutes, and there are no required signatures or forms to complete. The Medicare card will be sent to you via US mail. Information needed will include date of birth, place of birth, and current health insurance (beginning and end dates for Group coverage). You will be able to manage benefits online and view information and provided services.

To apply online, you must have reached the age of 64 years and 9 months, and not currently covered for Medicare. Also, you should not currently be receiving Social Security benefits. Parts A and B can be applied for online. You won't have to visit a Social Security office, and corrections can be made to your application before submission. A receipt is provided, and the status can be easily checked.


Are The Quotes Provided On This Website Free?

Yes. After you enter your zip code, some additional simple information is needed. Once that is provided, very quickly, you can review multiple offers. You can also compare other Senior healthcare options in Pa  if you have not reached age 65 yet. A private policy is available from most of the top carriers, although the OE period is different. For example, for 2019 plans, Open Enrollment ran from November 1 to December 15. Most applications are processed online, since it is the quickest option, and most efficient.

However, you can still apply for coverage outside of the OE period with a "qualifying event." Moving to a different service area, adopting a child, divorce, and losing credible coverage are four examples. When COBRA ends, you are provided an SEP exception.However, if you voluntarily terminate COBRA outside of the OE period, a qualifying event does not occur.


Can You Switch From One Plan To Another?


Enroll in Pa Medigap plans during Open Enrollment. Review and compare Pennsylvania Medicare Supplement coverage.


As we discussed earlier, you can often change or switch plans, but it's important to only change if there is a good reason. For example, if your current policy does not provide specific benefits you need, or you are paying for coverage that is never used, it may be worthwhile to consult us, or a licensed professional of your choice to review alternatives. And of course, affordability should always be considered.

But never cancel existing coverage before you secure alternative benefits. Also, if you have a strong preference for keeping your existing providers (primary-care physician, specialist, OBGYN, hospital, etc...) verify (we can help) that you will still be able to continue to use them. Network provider lists generally change each year, so it is possible that additional medical facilities could become available. Also, carriers will occasionally change their "service area," so specific counties may be added or deleted effective January 1.


What Type Of Benefits Are Covered?

"Basic" benefits must always be included. However, there can be differences, depending on the policy. Plans are designated by letters, starting at A and ending at N. More complete information can be obtained by contacting us or viewing the official US government handbook here. Many preventative services are covered at 100%, including annual physicals and screenings. NOTE: Electronic Medical Notices (eMSNs) can be requested so that you receive your "Medicare Summary Notice" monthly via email. New ID cards will no longer show your social security number. This improved security should reduce the risk of identity theft.

A quick synopsis: Part A is the hospital insurance benefit which includes inpatient, skilled nursing, home health, and hospice care. Part B includes treatment from physicians, medical equipment, outpatient care and some preventative benefits. If you have already enrolled in Part A (but not Part B), Form CMS 40-B must be completed. Part C is the "Advantage" plan option which is offered by private insurers. Dental and vision benefits are often included.  Part D is your drug coverage. Many Advantage plans include Part D benefits. However, several Advantage contracts are also offered without prescription drug benefits. Depending on your household income, financial assistance may be available to hel pay for some prescription costs.


Is Long-Term Care Covered?

Although some plans may offer some very basic benefits, typically, long-term health care is not provided on most Medigap plans. And when benefits are provided, they are very limited. Since facility treatment can be incredibly expensive without this type of policy, you may wish to request a quote, and we will help you find and compare the most affordable plans. Since they are underwritten, you may have to medically qualify. Activities of daily living are typically some of the main benefits of LTC plans. Examples include going to the bathroom, bathing, dressing, and cooking. Most contracts will provide reimbursement (up to policy limits) for care provided in your home, an assisted living facility, a Senior day care center, or a nursing home.

Several of the larger carriers that offer this type of plan (also called custodial care) include John Hancock, Mutual Of Omaha, MassMutual, New York Life, Northwestern, and Genworth. Many large companies previously offered this type of policy, but no longer allow you to purchase new plans. MetLife, for instance, continues to service in-force contracts, but will not issue a new policy.


How Are Rates Determined?

Each company decides the premium they will charge based on anticipated revenue and expenses. Shown below are the three  methods that the carrier can use to determine rates.

Issue Age - Your price is based on how old you are at the time you buy the policy. Naturally, someone who purchases coverage at age 65 will pay a lower premium than a 75 year-old. However, price differences between ages 65 and 66 are not significant.

Community-Rated -  Also referred to as "No-Age-Rated-Pricing." All persons pay the same rate regardless of age, medical status or pre-existing conditions. Sometimes older applicants can receive favorable pricing. Premiums can increase due to increased costs and inflation.

Attained-Age - You pay a rate based on your age at the time of purchase. However, as you get older, the premium increases. Initially, you'll pay less than a policy that is based on "Issue-Age." But the longer you live, the higher the premium becomes.


What Are Some Common Exclusions?

Dental-related expenses such as checkups, extractions and dentures are not covered. Also, eye exams, glasses and contact lenses are excluded. Private duty nurses and long-term care are typically not included in benefits. Acupuncture and cosmetic procedures and surgeries are also typically not covered.  However, you can separately purchase dental and vision policies through many of the top-rated carriers. Also, many Advantage plans provide dental, vision, and hearing benefits.


Are AARP Plans Offered In Pennsylvania?

Yes. For example, in most areas, Plans A, B, C, F, K, L, and N are available. A is the least expensive option, although it may not be the most cost-effective solution in many situations. UnitedHealthcare underwrites all AARP plans. "Advantage" plans offered and underwritten by UnitedHealthcare include MedicareComplete, MedicareComplete Choice, MedicareComplete Choice 1, MedicareComplete Choice 2, andMedicareComplete Plans 1, 2, and 3. The UHC nationwide network of physicians, hospitals, and other medical facilities is used.


What Are Some Of The Companies That Offer Medigap Plans In Pennsylvania?

There many participating companies, but listed below are some of the major carriers. Please keep in mind that this is only a partial list, and they are listed in alphabetical order and not in the order of rate competitiveness. The DOI also dedicates a page with some free information.



American Republic



Capital Blue Cross

Central States

Colonial Penn

Companion Life








Independence Blue Cross

Liberty National

Loyal American

Manhattan Life


Mutual Of Omaha


Philadelphia American

Physician's Mutual


State Farm



United American






Which Plans Cover BOTH The Part A and Part B Deductibles?

C and F cover both deductibles.  Both of these options also cover the Part A and B coinsurance (for an additional 365 days) along with hospice care and skilled nursing facility coinsurance. Some other plans only cover 50% or 75% of these expenses. Also, the F plan pays excess B charges while C does not. Although not usually needed, both provide foreign travel benefits.The first three pints of blood are also covered.

Of course, there are many other Pa Medicare Supplement plan provisions. To review specific prices and/or benefits, simply contact us or review the free quotes that we provide. Our goal is to provide the most helpful unbiased expertise so you can view the lowest Supplement prices in Pennsylvania.


Is a Stand-Alone Prescription Drug Plan In Pa Available?

Yes. There are many comparison tools that allow you to calculate the best option, based on the specific prescriptions you take, which pharmacies you prefer, and  the actual price of the drugs you are prescribed. Most importantly, it's critical to ensure that any drugs you are taking are covered under this stand-alone policy. Also, this option is typically not offered if you have an Advantage plan. These contracts must include comparable Part A and B benefits, and typically drug coverage is also included. Several Part D plans (PDP) are listed below:

Envision RxPlus

Avalon SecureRx Options 1 and 3

SilverScipt Choice 

SilverScript Plus

Highmark Blue Rx PDP Complete and PDP Plus

Express Scripts Medicare - Choice , Saver, and Value

AARP MedicareRx Preferred

AARP MedicareRx Saver Plus

AARP MedicareRx Walgreens

First Health Part D Premier Plus and Value Plus

UnitedHealthcare Symphonix Value Rx

Humana WalMart Rx Plan

Humana Preferred Rx Plan

Humana Enhanced

Aetna Medicare Rx Saver

Aetna Medicare Rx Select

Cigna-HealthSpring Rx Secure-Extra

Cigna-HealthSpring Rx Secure

WellCare Classic And Extra

Magellan Rx Medicare Basic 

Basic Blue Rx

Blue Rx Complete

Blue Rx PDP Complete

Blue Rx PDP Plus

SecureRx Option 1 and Option 3

Symphonix Value Rx


What Is A Part C Plan?

These are "Medicare Advantage" plans and are operated by private insurance companies. Many of these carriers also offer Medigap coverage, which does not involve Plan C. These policies are government-regulated and typically offer very low premiums. Sometimes, the premium is $0. Plan availability can vary, depending on your county of residence. Benefits and out-of-pocket costs can also vary. You can not have a supplement AND an Advantage plan. We have listed several of the highest-rated (US News And World Report) options below:

Erickson Advantage Signature, Advantage Guardian, Advantage Champion, Advantage Freedom.

AARP MedicareComplete Choice Plan 1 and 2, MedicareComplete, MedicareComplete Plans 1, 2, and 3.

Highmark Senior Health Community Blue Medicare HMO Prestige, HMO Signature, Freedom Blue PPO Classic, Freedom Blue PPO Deluxe, Freedom Blue PPO Select, Freedom Blue PPO Standard, Freedom Blue PPO ValueRx, 

Highmark Choice Security Blue HMO Deluxe, Security Blue HMO Standard, Security Blue HMO ValueRx,

Geisinger Gold Classic Advantage Rx, Gold Preferred Complete Rx, Gold Classic Complete Rx, Preferred Advantage Rx, Gold Secure Rx.

UPMC for Life HMO Deductible With Rx, HMO Rx Enhanced, HMO Rx, Options, PPO High Deductible with Rx,  PPO Rx Enhanced, For Life Dual.

HealthAmerica Advantra Butler Prime, Advantra Cares, Advantra Choice Plan, Advantra Fayette Advantra Prime, Gold, Advantra Northern Pennsylvania Gold,  AdvantraOne, Advantra Penn Highlands Prime, Advantra Silver, Advantra Silver Plus, Advantra Washington Prime.

Aetna Medicare Choice Plan, Gold Plan, Main Line Health Prime Plan, PinnicleHealth Prime Plan, Premier Plan, Standard Plan. 

Capital Advantage BlueJourney Classic, BlueJourney Essential, BlueJourney Value, BlueJourney Premier,  BlueJourney Prime.

Keystone Health Plan Central BlueJourney Essential, BlueJourney Essential, BlueJourney Premier, BlueJourney Value. 

Geisinger Gold Preferred Advantage Rx, Gold Preferred Complete Rx. 

UnitedHealthcare Assisted Living Plan, Nursing Home Plan, Dual Complete, Dual Complete ONE, 

Cigna-HealthSpring Achieve, Preferred, Preferred Plus, PreventiveCare, TotalCare, Traditions. 

Gateway Health Medical Assured Diamond, Ruby, Select.

Health Partners Medicare Prime, Special, Value.

HumanaChoice - H5525-005, H5525-006,  H5525-007, H5525-017, H6609-085, R5826-002.

Humana Gold Choice - H8145-052, H8145-053.

Humana Gold Plus - H6859-001, H6859-003, H6859-004, H6859-008.

Keystone - 65 Focus Rx, 65 Preferred Rx, 65 Select Rx.

Personal Choice - 65 Rx.

Vista Health - Amerihealth VIP Care, Keystone VIP Choice.

Provider Partners Pennsylvania Advantage Plan - HMO, HMO SNP.

Vibra Health - Enhanced Coverage


What Are Pennsylvania Public School Employees Retirement System (PSERS) Options?

PSERS offers choices through the "Health Options Program."  The employee, spouse,other dependents, and survivors are eligible for benefits before and after Medicare-eligibility. Eligibility is required, and plan participating is voluntary. Supplement options are "HOP" and "Value" medical plans. Prescription drug plan options (Part D) are "Enhanced", "Basic," and "Value" Medicare RX. Dental coverage provided by MetLife is also offered along with Advantage plans. For persons under age 65, HOP Pre-65 and a Managed-Care plan can be considered. A "Substantial Premium Subsidy" of $100 per month can be used to lower premiums for qualified applicants.


What Services Are Offered By The Pa Department Of Aging?

Many free programs are offered to Keystone State residents. Several popular services include  caregiver support, help at home, housing, prescriptions, transportation, meals, protective services, employment, and ombudsman. A free healthcare counseling program is also offered. APPRISE provides counselors and other resources that can assist with your Medigap questions. The Department Of Aging also provides assistance to the elderly, and any person with dementia-related disease or other brain syndromes.

APPRISE workers can also make presentations to organizations and groups, and assist Seniors with the Medicare appeal process, eligibility and enrollment, how to apply for financial assistance, and understanding long term care plans and benefits. Volunteers are also needed to explain benefits to members of the program.


Additional Information:

Independence Blue Cross will not be increasing premiums on most of its Medicare Advantage plans. In specific counties (Philadelphia and Bucks), rates for Personal Choice 65 PPO plans will substantially decrease. The SilverSneakers fitness benefit will remain on the Advantage plans and the list of network providers will remain very large.

For New Jersey residents that move from Pennsylvania, changing Med-Supp plans is not needed. However, contacting the current carrier is needed so future billing, plan changes and any other information can be sent to the correct location. However, your Part D must be changed since it is based on the zip code or county where you live. Often, you can remain with the same company.


Fall Open Enrollment, which began in October, ends December 7th. If you become newly-eligible throughout the year, you also can enroll.


Fall Open Enrollment for Medicare begins on October 15th and continues through December 7th. During this time, you can change to or from a Medicare Advantage Plan (including an MSA). For 2018 effective dates, several of the available Advantage policies in Pennsylvania that feature a $0 premium include:

Advantra Basic Medical

Advantra Choice Plan

Advantra Silver

Advantra Beaver Valley Prime

Allwell Medicare

Advantra Basic Medical

Advantra Northern Pennsylvania Gold

Community Blue Medicare HMO Signature

HumanaChoice H5216-116

HumanaChoice R0923-001

Humana Gold Plus H6622-035

Humana Gold Plus H6622-043

UPMC For Life

UPMC For Life HMO Premier Rx 

BlueJourney Essential

Geisinger Gold Essential Rx

Geisinger Gold Preferred Complete Rx

Vibra Health Plan Essential Coverage